The reading chosen for this day appears to be in direct contradiction to the message of Christianity. The three readings for the 17th Sunday after Pentecost are Isaiah 50:4-10 (Gave my back and cheeks); James 2:1-5, 8-10, 14-18 (Faith without works is dead) and Mark 8:27-35 (Peter’s confession). The passage chosen to elaborate is James 2:17 reading, “Thus also faith by itself, if it does not have works is dead.”
How can one possibly reconcile this verse with those of the apostle Paul who reveals that we are saved by grace, through faith, apart from works lest anyone should boast? Once more the distinctions between Law and Gospel come to our rescue keeping in mind the queen of theology which is context.
For example, I could have one conversation about proving that a person with two legs is a human being. Soon thereafter I could have another conversation proving that a person with one leg is a human being. And then I could have a third conversation proving that a person with no legs is a human being. Are these contradictory statements? No, not if the people of whom I am speaking have two legs, then one leg and then no legs because of war.
So also, to whom is Paul and James writing? Paul is writing to those who insist as did the Judaizers in that day that becoming saved takes more than faith–it takes circumcision and the following of other ceremonial and moral laws. Paul’s point is to reveal that justification is by faith alone without any help at all from works.
James is writing to those who think that faith is believing that Jesus lived, that He was born of the virgin, died on a cross and rose from the dead. James reminds us that such faith is that of the devils and they tremble because it is NOT saving faith. For saving faith consists not just of knowledge and assent but also of trust in the promises of God connected to the events of Jesus’ life.
However, James is making the point that those who imagine that knowledge and assent are sufficient are in error. For true faith always results in works of God; that is, fruit of the Holy Spirit such as trusting Jesus, love and helping others. Though Paul is correct that faith and faith alone justifies, James is correct that true saving faith always results in fruit of the Spirit or else it is dead faith.
God is the author of both the letters of Paul and James. He never errs nor contradicts Himself. Thus, keeping in mind the two audiences that each of the apostles have in mind, we conclude that both Paul and James teach that faith alone justifies but faith never remains alone as the fruit of the Holy Spirit becomes evident to God as He reads the hearts of those who are motivated through love of Jesus Christ. It is not just Paul who should be considered an apostle of faith; it is also James.
Name:Tom Baker